Key takeaways
- Spot suits irregular cargoes, a time charter suits regular programmes, and a COA gives predictable freight without a ship of your own.
- On a COA, the details that matter are nomination periods, volume tolerances, ship approval and the freight adjustment.
- If more than half of a year's cargoes are predictable, a COA or time charter usually beats fixing every cargo spot.
LPG importers, traders and end users ask us the same first question: should we fix this cargo on the spot market, take a ship on time charter, or sign a contract of affreightment (COA)? The answer depends on how regular your volumes are, how much freight risk you want to carry, and how specific your terminals are.
The three structures side by side
| Voyage (spot) | Time charter | COA | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $ per tonne, per voyage | Hire per day or month | $ per tonne, fixed or index-linked |
| Bunkers and port costs | Owner | Charterer | Owner |
| Speed and waiting risk | Owner, except laytime | Charterer | Owner, except laytime |
| Ship choice | Each voyage | One named ship | Owner nominates approved ships |
| Typical forms | GASVOY or charterer's form | GASTIME or Shelltime-based | Voyage terms plus COA clauses |
When spot fits
Spot suits irregular cargoes, trading opportunities and first-time lanes. You pay the market of the day and the owner carries voyage costs and speed risk, but you have no guarantee of a ship when you need one. In the small pressurised market a ship can be the only suitable one in the region for weeks, so we start looking before your laycan is final.
When a time charter fits
A time charter gives you a named ship for 6 months to several years. You pay hire and take on bunkers, port costs and the commercial employment of the ship, so you profit when you use it well and pay for idle days. It suits regular programmes, terminals with strict ship approvals, and buyers who want the same crew and ship at their berths every time.
When a COA fits
A COA commits the owner to carry an agreed volume over a period, such as 24 cargoes a year with a tolerance either side, without naming a single ship. It suits regular distribution into Türkiye, the Med or West Africa when you want predictable freight but not a ship of your own. The details that matter are nomination periods, volume tolerances, ship approval, and the freight adjustment for bunkers or a market index.
Ammonia and petrochemical gases
Ammonia needs ships with suitable tank materials and certification, and terminals often restrict previous cargoes. Petrochemical gases such as propylene and butadiene have their own quality and inhibitor requirements. On any structure, write the cargo grades, previous-cargo rules and who pays for grade changes into the fixture.
Practical takeaway
Map one year of expected cargoes before choosing. If more than half are predictable in size and timing, a COA or time charter usually beats fixing every cargo spot; keep the rest on the spot market for flexibility.